Rating system
I employ a five-star system. A must-see movie is four stars or better. More details on my rating system
Flags and Remarks
Some movies are labelled with flags that indicate content which may be inappropriate for certain viewers. Flags are in the form of a letter followed by a number, such as A2. The letter indicates the nature of the potentially offensive content, and the number indicates the degree (1=minor, 2=moderate, 3=major). The letters are coded as follows: violence (V), nudity (N), strong language (L), adult situations (A), substance abuse (S), vulgarity/adult humor (H), mature themes (M), and graphic/scary/bloody imagery (I). All flags are based on my opinion, and are intended to serve as guidelines. Remarks indicate additional features of interest, such as the language (if not English), based on a true story (BOTS), director's cut (DC), etc.
Also on this page
Top 25 movies of all time
Top five lists
Best movies by year
Other Movie Sites
The top two movies sites I have found are AMG and IMDB. These sites are indispensible for the serious movie fan. For information on MPAA film ratings, see AMG or MPAA. An impressive collection of critics' lists can be found at Greatest Films. See also J's movie page, compiled by my main man and fellow movie lover, J Provine. And remember, if you disagree with my choices, by all means, make your own list.
Rating | Year | Title | Genre | Flags and Remarks |
1968 | 2001: A Space Odyssey | Science Fiction | ||
1986 | Aliens | Sci-Fi, Action, Suspense | V2. Sequel to Alien. | |
2002 | Attack of the Clones | Galactic Thriller | ||
1989 | Batman | Action, Fantsay | ||
1991 | Beauty & the Beast | Fantasy, Fairly Tale | Animated | |
1948 | The Bicycle Thief | Drama | Italian | |
1980 | Blues Brothers | Comedy | L1 | |
1957 | The Bridge on the River Kwai | War | V1 | |
1969 | Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid | Western, Comedy | L1, V1 | |
1942 | Casablanca | Drama | ||
1958 | Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Drama | ||
1941 | Citizen Kane | Drama | ||
1974 | The Conversation | Psychological Thriller | L1, A2 | |
1967 | Cool Hand Luke | Drama, Comedy | L1, A1 | |
2000 | Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon | Adventure, Action | Mandarin | |
2008 | The Dark Knight | Fantasy, Drama | I3, M3, V3. | |
2012 | The Dark Knight Rises | Fantasy, Drama | I3, M3, V3. | |
1995 | Dead Man Walking | Drama | I2, M3, BOTS. | |
1989 | Dead Poets Society | Drama | A1 | |
1954 | Diabolique | Suspense | French | |
1964 | Dr. Strangelove | War, Comedy, Satire | H1, I1 | |
1980 | The Empire Strikes Back | Space Adventure | ||
1940 | Fantasia | Fantasy, Musical | Animated | |
2011 | From Up on Poppy Hill | Drama | Animated | |
2003 | Fog of War | Pseudo-Documentary, Cold War | I3 | |
1987 | Full Metal Jacket | War | V3, L3 | |
1972 | The Godfather | Drama, Crime | V2, M3 | |
1974 | The Godfather II | Drama, Crime | V2, M3 | |
1939 | Gone With the Wind | Drama, Civil War | ||
1967 | The Graduate | Drama | N1, A2 | |
2013 | Gravity | Drama, Suspense | M1, V1 | |
2000 | High Fidelity | Urban Comedy, Drama | A1, L3 | |
1986 | Hoosiers | Sports Drama | ||
1961 | The Hustler | Drama | A1 | |
2004 | The Incredibles | Superhero, Action | V1, Animated | |
2015 | Inside Out | Fantasy, Drama | Animated | |
1946 | It's a Wonderful Life | Drama, Comedy | ||
1975 | Jaws | Horror, Suspense | I2 | |
1955 | Lady & the Tramp | Dog Film | Animated | |
1997 | Life is Beautiful | Drama | M3 | |
1998 | Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels | Crime, Comedy | V2, L3 | |
1941 | The Maltese Falcon | Detective Film, Film Noir | V1 | |
1966 | A Man For All Seasons | Religious Drama | M2 | |
1956 | The Man Who Knew Too Much | Spy Thriller | ||
1962 | The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance | Western, Outlaw | V1 | |
1962 | The Manchurian Candidate | Cold War Psychological Thriller | M1 | |
2005 | March of the Penguins | Documentary | ||
1999 | The Matrix | Sci-Fi, Action | V3, L1 | |
1947 | Miracle on 34th Street | Children's Movie | ||
1942 | Mrs. Miniver | Drama, WWII | M1 | |
1988 | My Neighbor Totoro | Fantasy, Children's Movie | Animated, Japanese | |
1944 | National Velvet | Children's Drama | ||
1984 | Nausicaa of the Valley of Wind | Fantasy | Animated, Japanese | |
1977 | A New Hope | Extra-Terrestrial Epic | ||
1959 | North by Northwest | Suspense | ||
1954 | On the Waterfront | Drama, Crime | V1 | |
1980 | Ordinary People | Drama | ||
1923 | Our Hospitality | Comedy | Silent. | |
1999 | The Phantom Menace | Interplanetary Drama | ||
1994 | Il Postino | Drama | Italian | |
1987 | Predator | Action | V3 | |
1960 | Psycho | Suspense, Horror | V2 | |
1981 | Raiders of the Lost Ark | Adventure | ||
1980 | Raging Bull | Drama | L3, M2 | |
2007 | Ratatouille | Adventure, Comedy | Animated | |
1954 | Rear Window | Mystery, Thriller | ||
1983 | Return of the Jedi | Interstellar Saga | ||
2005 | Revenge of the Sith | Cosmic Fantasy | M1 | |
1998 | Run Lola Run | Action, Comedy, Techno | German | |
1993 | Schindler's List | Historical Drama, War | M3, N1, I2 | |
1954 | Seven Samurai | Drama, Period Film | V2, L1, Japanese | |
1994 | The Shawshank Redemption | Drama | V1, A1 | |
2001 | Spirited Away | Fantasy | I1, Animated, Japanese | |
1973 | The Sting | Crime, Comedy, Drama | L1, V1 | |
1984 | The Terminator | Action, Sci-Fi | V3,N1 | |
1949 | The Third Man | Drama, Mystery | V1 | |
1986 | Top Gun | Drama, Action | L1, A1 | |
1995 | Toy Story | Drama | Animated | |
1999 | Toy Story II | Drama | Animate | |
2010 | Toy Story III | Drama | Animated | |
1939 | The Wizard of Oz | Fantasy | ||
1959 | The Young Philadelphians | Drama |
Rating | Year | Title | Genre | Flags and Remarks |
2001 | Amelie | Comedy, Romance | H2, N1. French | |
2009 | Avatar | Sci-Fi | V2, I2 | |
1942 | Bambi | Fantasy, Drama | Animated. | |
2005 | Batman Begins | Fantasy | V1 | |
1998 | The Big Lebowski | Comedy | N2, L3 | |
1963 | The Birds | Suspense | I2 | |
1979 | The Black Stallion | Drama | ||
2002 | Bowling for Columbine | Pseudo-Documentary | I3, L2 | |
2005 | Cars | Drama, Action | Animated | |
1963 | Charade | Romantic Mystery, Suspense | I1 | |
1981 | Chariots of Fire | Drama | BOTS | |
1931 | City Lights | Drama | Silent | |
1981 | Das Boot | War, Submarine Movie | DC | |
1973 | The Day of the Jackal | Psychological Thriller, Hitman Movie | V1, N1 | |
1981 | The Fox and the Hound | Drama, Children's Movie | Animated | |
1971 | The French Connection | Action, Detective Film | ||
1966 | Gambit | Heist | ||
1927 | The General | Comedy | Silent | |
1939 | Goodbye, Mr. Chips | Drama | ||
2009 | Gran Torino | Drama | L3, V3, M3 | |
1950 | Harvey | Comedy | ||
2004 | Hotel Rwanda | Political Drama | M2, I2. | |
2005 | Howl's Moving Castle | Fantasy | Animated, Japanese | |
1963 | Hud | Western | V1 | |
1990 | The Hunt for Red October | Cold War Thriller, Submarine Movie | V2 | |
1989 | Kiki's Delivery Service | Fantasy | Animated, Japanese. | |
2008 | Kung Fu Panda | Fantasy, Action | Animated. | |
1961 | Judgment at Nuremberg | Drama | ||
1994 | Laura | Mystery | ||
2004 | Mystic River | Drama | V2, M3 | |
2001 | Nine Queens | Crime | Argentinian | |
2007 | No Country for Old Men | Crime, Suspense | V2, I2 | |
2000 | O Brother, Where Art Thou? | Comedy, Crime | V1 | |
1959 | On the Beach | Cold War, Disaster | M3 | |
2002 | The Pianist | Holocaust | M3, V2, I3, L1 | |
1964 | The Pink Panther | Comedy, Mystery | ||
2009 | Ponyo | Fantasy | Animated | |
1997 | Princess Mononoke | Fantasy | V1, I1, Animated, Japanese | |
1985 | Ran | Tragedy | Japanese | |
1951 | Rashoman | Enigmatic Drama | Japanese | |
1959 | Rio Bravo | Western | ||
1976 | Rocky | Drama | A1 | |
1948 | Rope | Psychological Thriller | V1 | |
1954 | Sabrina | Romance, Comedy | ||
1951 | A Streetcar Named Desire | Drama | A1 | |
1978 | Superman | Science Fiction, Action | ||
1980 | Superman II | Science Fiction, Action | ||
1991 | Terminator 2: Judgment Day | Action, Science Fiction | V3 | |
1934 | The Thin Man | Mystery | ||
1992 | Unforgiven | Western | V3, M3 | |
2009 | Up | Adventure | Animated | |
1995 | The Usual Suspects | Suspense, Crime | V3, L3 | |
2008 | WALL-E | Fantasy | Animated | |
1973 | The Way We Were | Drama | ||
2003 | Whale Rider | Drama |
Rating | Year | Title | Genre | Flags and Remarks |
1992 | Aladdin | Fantasy | Animated | |
1979 | Alien | Sci-Fi Thriller | V2 | |
1976 | All the President's Men | Political Drama | M1, A1, L1. BOTS | |
1984 | Amadeus | Drama | A1, L1 | |
2008 | Appaloosa | Western | V2 | |
1995 | Apollo 13 | Historical Drama | BOTS | |
1997 | As Good As It Gets | Romantic Comedy | A1 | |
1985 | Back to the Future | Adventure | ||
1987 | Babette's Feast | Drama | M2 | |
2002 | The Bourne Identity | Action, Spy Film | V3, L2 | |
1954 | The Bridges at Toko-Ri | War | V1 | |
1998 | Buena Vista Social Club | Documentary | ||
2006 | Casino Royale | Action, Spy Movie | V2 | |
1986 | Castle in the Sky | Fantasy | Animated, Japanese. | |
1977 | Close Encounters of the Third Kind | Science Fiction | ||
1997 | Contact | Science Fiction | V1, A1 | |
2004 | The Corporation | Pseudo-Documentary | ||
1950 | Cyrano de Bergerac | Drama | ||
2010 | Despicable Me | Comedy, Family Movie | ||
1954 | Dial M for Murder | Crime Thriller | V1 | |
1988 | Die Hard | Action Thriller | V2 | |
1962 | Divorce - Italian Style | Satire | Italian | |
1996 | The English Patient | Drama, Romance | V1, A2, I2 | |
1982 | E.T. The Extra Terrestrial | Science Fiction | ||
2001 | The Fellowship of the Ring | Fantasy Adventure | I2 | |
1993 | The Firm | Crime Thriller | A2 | |
1998 | Following | Psychological Drama | ||
1984 | Ghostbusters | Comedy | I1 | |
1989 | Glory | Civil War | I2, V2. BOTS | |
1940 | The Great Dictator | Political Satire | ||
1963 | The Great Escape | WWII, Prisoners of War | V1,M1. BOTS | |
1966 | The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly | Western | V2 | |
1937 | The Grand Illusion | War | French | |
1994 | Hoop Dreams | Documentary | L2 | |
1967 | Hombre | Western | V1, M1 | |
2008 | Horton Hears a Who | Fantasy | Animated | |
2002 | The Importance of Being Earnest | Comedy | ||
1993 | In the Name of the Father | Political Drama | M3, V3 | |
1989 | Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade | Adventure | I1 | |
1960 | Inherit the Wind | Historical Drama, Religious | BOTS | |
1999 | The Iron Giant | Children's Fantasy | Animated | |
1994 | The Iron Monkey | Action, Kung-Fu | In Mandarin | |
1986 | Jean de Florette | Drama, Foreign | French | |
1993 | Jurassic Park | Science Fiction | I2 | |
1984 | The Karate Kid | Drama | ||
1956 | The Killing | Crime, Suspense | V1 | |
1979 | Kramer vs. Kramer | Drama | M2 | |
1997 | L.A. Confidential | Mystery, Drama, Crime | L3, N2, V2, I1 | |
1989 | The Little Mermaid | Fantasy | Animated | |
1962 | The Longest Day | War | V1 | |
1981 | Mad Max 2: The Road Warrior | Action, Post-apocalyptic | V3 | |
1986 | Manon of the Spring | Drama, Foreign | N2. Sequel to Jean de Florette. | |
2000 | Memento | Psychological Thriller | V3 | |
1927 | Metropolis | Science Fiction | Silent, German | |
2005 | Million Dollar Baby | Drama, Boxing | M1, V1 | |
1974 | Monty Python and the Holy Grail | Comedy | A1, H2 | |
1939 | Mr. Smith Goes to Washington | Drama | ||
1984 | The Natural | Drama, Baseball | A1 | |
1994 | Nobody's Fool | Drama | N2, M1 | |
1976 | The Outlaw Josey Wales | Western | V3 | |
2007 | Persepolis | Drama | Foreign, Animated | |
1998 | The Prince of Egypt | Religous Epic | Animated | |
1993 | Philadelphia | Drama | M1, L2, A2 | |
2010 | Predators | Sci-Fi, Action | I2, V2 | |
1988 | Rain Man | Drama | L2, A2 | |
1987 | Raising Arizona | Comedy | L2 | |
1940 | Rebecca | Mystery | A1 | |
1955 | Rififi | Crime, Heist | French | |
1996 | The Rock | Action | V2 | |
1985 | Rocky IV | Sports | V1 | |
1987 | Robocop | Crime, Sci-Fi, Action | V3 | |
1998 | Saving Private Ryan | War | V3. BOTS. | |
1949 | The Setup | Drama, Boxing | V1 | |
1956 | Seven Men from Now | Western | V1 | |
1993 | Shadowlands | Drama | M1, BOTS | |
2003 | Spellbound | Documentary | ||
1965 | The Spy Who Came In From the Cold | Spy Film | ||
2004 | Super-Size Me | Pseudo-Documentary | N1, L1 | |
1999 | Sweet and Lowdown | Comedy, Satire | S1,A1. | |
2003 | Touching the Void | Pseudo-Documentary | ||
1974 | The Towering Inferno | Action | V1 | |
2002 | The Two Towers | Fantasy Adventure | I3 | |
2005 | Walk the Line | Drama | M1 | |
1996 | When We Were Kings | Documentary, Boxing | "Rumble in the Jungle" | |
2003 | Winged Migration | Documentary |
The next few . . .
Action
War
Epics
Cold War
Comedy
Foreign
Directed by Alfred Hitchcock
Religious
Westerns
Chase Scenes
Sports
Documentary
Pseudo-Documentary
Spy Movies
Starring Robert Redford
Robots
Boxing Movies
|
Sequels
Star Wars
Disney Animated Features (Non-Pixar)
Pixar Features
Directed by Hayao Miyazaki
Main Themes
Instrumental Soundtracks
Original Pop Soundtracks
Compiled Pop Soundtracks
Based on a True Story (non-documentary)
Directed by Stephen Spielberg
Starring Paul Newman (my favorite actor)
Comic Superhero Movies
Good Scary Movies (in order of scariness)
Detective/PI movies
Coen Brothers
Diminished by Violence/Graphic Imagery
|
A || separates must-see from non-must-see-but-still-entertaining.
I employ a five-star system, summarized by the table below: A must-see movie is four stars or better.
5.0 | Engrossing, memorable, highly recommendable, and worth seeing several times. The best of the best. | |
4.5 | Falls just short of one or more of the five-star criteria, but still an excellent movie. | |
4.0 | One or more well-defined shortcomings, but still good enough to be mandatory viewing. | |
3.5 | Highly enjoyable but not quite essential. | |
3.0 | Entertaining and worth seeing once. | |
2.5 | Tolerable, some redeeming qualities, but ultimately unsatisfying. | |
2.0 | A mediocre, uninspiring movie. | |
1.5 | You spend the whole movie waiting for it to be over. | |
1.0 | Difficult to bear, possibly nauseating, horrendous. Avoid this movie at all costs. |
One may also think in terms of the five-star system used by Netflix, which is essentially equivalent although less nuanced. Their system is: [5 = I loved it; 4 = I really liked it; 3 = I liked it; 2 = OK; 1 = I didn't like it].
I think of a must-see movie as follows: Suppose you have a friend who really likes movies, and who has the exact same tastes as you. He or she derives significant pleasure from viewing a high quality flick, although watching so-so or bad movies annoys them. A must-see movie is one that, soon after viewing it, you highly recommend to that friend.
My goal in rating movies is not to create an unbiased, objective ranking of the great films of history that any logical person could arrive at by applying a set of well-defined principles. I do not fashion myself a "film critic." This list is entirely biased and subjective, based on my personal opinions, which are in turn shaped by my life experiences, values, personality, and emotional tendencies. I do, however, follow certain guidelines, outlined above, that I believe most movie fans would agree characterize a must-see movie. For you to fully know how my personal opinions are manifested in the implementation of my ranking system, I could write a treatise on the world according to Clay, but I don't have time for that right now so you'll just have to see the movies and figure it out for yourself.
I generally do not give much weight to the opinions of professional movie critics, although this is difficult to avoid completely. I also give little weight to the historical importance of a movie. I give no weight to box-office success or Academy Awards (no Titanic here).
I do give weight to movies that have historical importance in my life. For example, Batman will always be a five star movie for me because I still vividly remember walking out of the theater in 1989, at age 14, and being more stoked than I'd ever been about having just seen a movie. Other movies on this list that evoke nostalgia include Top Gun, Ghostbusters, and The Karate Kid.
This page is maintained by Clay Scott. Please email me with comments or suggestions.
visits since January 2, 2002.